A practical approach to calculate patent term adjustment pta. Novartis ruling leads to issuance of new patent terms. Novartis s businesses are divided into three operating divisions. If the united states patent and trademark office fails to examine a patent application in time deadlines for various steps are different, the patent term may be extended. But us patents frequently receive a longer term, mainly due to patent term adjustment pta. For most cases, the additional term adjustment will simply be the number of days between the notice of allowance and the issue date. Gatt, patent term was limited to 20 years from filing, in part to harmonize us patent law with our trade partners. Novartiss businesses are divided into three operating divisions. Patent alert federal circuit decision on patent term adjustment. Recently, the united states patent and trademark office proposed changes to the rules of practice pertaining to the patent term adjustment provisions in view of the decision by the united states court of appeals for the federal circuit in novartis ag v. On january 15, 2014, the court of appeals for the federal circuit cafc decided novartis ag v. The office, however, calculates the patent term adjustment manually when an applicant requests reconsideration of a patent term adjustment determination pursuant to 1. Federal circuit decision on patent term adjustment fish.
Novartis elected this patent to receive the fiveyear term extension. However, this comes often at the cost of losing patent term, for example, obtained as a result of properly obtained patent term adjustment pta, and also importantly, the cure is only prospective. We believe in the power of opensourced, global collaboration for the greater good. Patent term adjustment pta and patent term extension pte post supernus, novartis i, and novartis ii. Innovative medicines, sandoz generics and alcon eyecare. The courts decision contained three significant holdings. Novartis filed law suits that challenged the determinations by the uspto of how much time to add to the patent term under 35 u.
The uspto has not yet issued guidance on when it will change its procedure for calculating. Uspto proposes changes to patent term adjustment in response. The modification of the offices patent term adjustment program required by the decision in novartis has now been completed, and the patent term adjustment determinations in patents issued on or after october 7, 2014 are consistent with the federal circuit decision in novartis and this final rule. Obviousnesstype double patenting does not invalidate. On january 15, 2014, the federal circuit issued its longawaited decision in novartis v. In 1994, congress changed the method of measuring the effective term of. Uspto finalizes patent term adjustment rules and is. Hitech pharmacal, the court of appeals for the federal circuit looked at the question of whether a patent term extension under the hatchwaxman act, 35 u. Reduction of period of adjustment of patent term bitlaw. Because of the very real patent office delays, congress created a system of patent term adjustment pta that adds additional time to the patent term based upon unreasonable delays in issuing the patent rights that would have otherwise shortened the effective patent term. In the final rule changes to patent term adjustment in view of the federal circuit decision in novartis v.
The united states patent and trademark office pto issued a final rule regarding the effect of filing a request for continued examination rce on patent term. Federal circuit makes important change in patent term adjustment determinations. Thus, if the term adjustment for a particular patent is important, the calculated term adjustment needs to be checked for accuracy. Novartis ag inventions, patents and patent applications. Patent term extension granted for some applications filed. Lee, the federal circuit recently ruled that the u. The disclosure relates to novel regimens for treating psoriasis, which employ a therapeutically effective amount of an il17 antagonist, e. The deadline for filing a lawsuit challenging a pta determination. Pta offers extra patent term to compensate for certain application processing delays at the united states patent and trademark office uspto. Final rule, changes to patent term adjustment in view of the federal circuit decision in novartis v. Patent term adjustment pta and patent term extension pte compensate a patent applicant for delays that occur during patent prosecution. See changes to implement patent term adjustment under twentyyear patent term, 65 fr 56365, 56370. The baseline term may then be modified by patent term adjustment, terminal disclaimers, and patent term extension.
Federal circuit makes important change in patent term. At the time of this articles inception, the patent office had still not issued any statement as to whether their patent term adjustment software has been modified to account for the novartis decision. History biological patents software patents list of patent law cases v t e. In an opinion issued on january 15, 2014 in novartis ag v. Uspto pta calculation calculating patent term adjustment post novartis.
Jan 21, 2014 on january 15, 2014, in novartis ag v. Novartis said that the emr was conferred for a period of five years, or until an order was passed on the patent claim in india, whichever was earlier. This case results in a minor shift in patent term adjustment pta for patents. Change in patent term from 17 years from issuance to 20 years from filing or national stage entry date. This listing includes patent applications that are pending as well as patents that have already been granted by the united states patent and trademark office uspto. In the last few months, there have been important developments relating to patent term adjustment pta determinations by the u. A compound of formula i, or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof, is provided that has been shown to be useful for the treatment of lysine kspecific demethylase 1a lsd1mediated diseases or disorders. This could result in the loss of many years in the effective term after patent issue. Extensions or other delay taken by the applicant can reduce or eliminate the extension. The recent case law developments relating to patent term adjustment involve b delay, which arises out of the statutory guarantee of no more than 3year application pendency set forth in 35 u. Novartis ag has filed for patents to protect the following inventions.
This extension is known as a patent term adjustment pta. Novartis seeks a judgment that the patent term for each of the novartis patents be increasedl as reflected in the attached exhibit a. Sep 03, 2014 at the time of this articles inception, the patent office had still not issued any statement as to whether their patent term adjustment software has been modified to account for the novartis decision. In addition, the modified term of a patent may be prematurely terminated by a number of events. Lee, the court of appeals for the federal circuit addressed certain issues concerning the calculation of patent term adjustment pta by the u. However, between 1995 and 2000, patent office delays cost patentees years of patent term. As such, an invalidation, even if temporary, often comes at a loss of damages for the period before the terminal disclaimer is filed during the period when the subsequent patent has already issued.
Federal circuit protects novartis gilenya patent from. Novartis filed for and secured a fiveyear patent term extension pte for the 229 patent pursuant to 35 u. Federal circuit partially clarifies obviousnesstype. New changes in us patent term adjustment calculations after. Novartis has two hundred and eighteen approved drugs.
Federal circuit backs novartis and exelixis in patent term. Congress to create a system of patent term adjustment pta to compensate patent holders for certain application processing. Novartis in 1997 applied for grant of patent for the drug glivec in the patent office in chennai. The first day of a patents term and provisional rights. This unique and interactive session will track a hypothetical life sciences patent portfolio and will delve into postgilead filing strategies and tactics to implement to maximize the strength of the portfolio while steering clear of double patenting challenges. Novartis ag is a publicly traded swiss holding company that operates through the novartis group. Patent term and patent term adjustment may 9, 2014 robert ashbrook dechert llp cira centre, 2929 arch street philadelphia, pa 19104 robert. Obviousnesstype double patenting does not invalidate patent.
The 229 patent was a gatt transitional patent filed in 1994, and its normal expiration date was 17 years from its. Several months of additional pta may now be added to a patent term if a request for continued examination rce was. Uspto proposes changes to patent term adjustment in. Court of appeals for the federal circuit affirms the delaware district courts final judgment concerning patent term extensions and the interplay with the. Patent and trademark offices usptos methodology for calculating patent term adjustment pta in cases where a request for continued examination. Congress to create a system of patent term adjustment pta to compensate patent holders for certain applicationprocessing delays at the u. Novartis obtained a 5 year patent term extension pte of the 229 patent under 35 usc 156, based on fda approval of gilenya. Novartis ag owns, directly or indirectly, all companies worldwide that operate as subsidiaries of the novartis group 117. This software modification required for measuring the fourteenmonth patent term adjustment period from the date of commencement of the national stage was completed in april of 2014. New changes in us patent term adjustment calculations. Lee case is that the vast majority of recently issued patents that include an rce in the file history are due additional patent term adjustment pta. Recent developments relating to patent term adjustments. Will patentees receive patent term adjustment after novartis.
Patent and trademark office has been incorrectly calculating patent term adjustment for patents issued. Court of appeals for the federal circuit affirms the delaware district courts final judgment concerning patent term extensions and the interplay with the obviousnesstype. There are one hundred and fortyseven us patents protecting novartis drugs. Deadline approaches for public comments on patent term adjustment. The us court of appeals for the federal circuit has upheld a ruling which found that the us patent and trademark office uspto had been incorrectly calculating patent term adjustment lengths pta. Will patentees receive patent term adjustment after. The office is now deciding requests for reconsideration of a patent term adjustment filed pursuant to 1. Lee novartis filed law suits that challenged the determinations by the uspto of how much time to add to the patent term under.
Uspto finalizes patent term adjustment rules and is accepting. In 1995, the united states changed its patent term from 17years from patent issuance to 20years from first application filing or national stage entry. In the united states, under current patent law, the term of patent, provided that maintenance. To remedy this, congress created patent term adjustment in 2001, which, in part, awarded extra patent. Obviousnesstype double patenting does not invalidate patent term extensions. Federal register changes to patent term adjustment in. The term of a patent which claims a product, a method of using a product, or a method of manufacturing a product shall be extended in accordance with this section from the original expiration date of the patent, which shall include any patent term adjustment granted under section154b. A chipping away of the gilead double patenting fiasco. The us district court for the eastern district of texas first ruled against the uspto on the issue in 2012, finding in favour of pharmaceutical.
Nov 26, 2012 novartis ag has filed for patents to protect the following inventions. The modification of the offices patent term adjustment program required by the decision in novartis has now been completed, and the patent term adjustment determinations in patents issued on or after october 7, 2014 are consistent with the. The new rulesdrafted in response to the federal circuits decision in novartis ag v. Calculating patent term adjustment postnovartis law360. On june 18, 2014, the patent office issued changes to how it calculates patent term adjustments under 35 u. Patents assigned to novartis ag justia patents search. The novartis institutes for biomedical research nibr is pioneering new informatics tools for drug discovery. Patent term extension is ok, even with a terminal disclaimer. Because a patent whose term can be further extended by pte will often be extended to the same date regardless of whether that patents term was extended due to pto delay, patent owners should consider seeking pte for a patent that does not already have a patent term adjustment due to pto delay. If the patent takes longer than three years from the application filing date to grant, the life of the patent is extended one day for each day after the end of the threeyear period until the patent has issued. Patent term adjustment hereinafter pta is not rocketscience and to enable you with the prowess to dive into the deep understanding of statutory requirements for the pta without getting caught up with the trickiness of a legal draft, we provide a practical approach to explaining the fundamentals of pta in a most simplified and easytounderstand.
404 1453 361 317 326 1143 542 901 174 1504 738 1302 169 1135 1434 538 140 340 227 1492 210 658 257 1068 206 121 1060 1113 818 73 759 290 1314 135 1107 1053